U.S. Bank Stock Portfolio: New Domestic Portfolio Designed to Repeat Stellar Performance

by Gene Kirsch, Senior Banking Analyst | October 30, 2012

See also: Weiss Ratings Series – U.S. Bank Portfolio

Our first domestic bank stock portfolio wrapped up with 10 of 14 picks outperforming their target price and 7 of 14 reaching their book value price. Overall, the undervalued portfolio had a 31.07 percent return for nine months ended October 26. The charts below show the final individual stock performance and monthly portfolio performance:

After the carnage in domestic banking stocks during 2011, especially the large money center banks like Bank of America (down 58 percent), Citigroup (down -44 percent) and Wells Fargo (down 41 percent), the turnaround in 2012 so far has been just as remarkable: 

These four largest banks control 56 percent of all U.S. banking assets and 50 percent of all revenues. As these four banks go, so goes the entire U.S. banking sector. In that regard, the KBW Banking Index (BKX), a weighted index of 24 geographically diverse stocks representing national money centers and leading regional institutions, gained 15.7 percent in 2012 through October 26. This includes the four largest banks plus others like SunTrust Bank (up 46.3 percent).  However, PNC Financial has lost another 2.2 percent so far in 2012 on top of the 5 percent decline in 2011. The S&P Banking Index, a much broader banking index that includes all banks in the Standard & Poors, is up 10.2 percent so far in 2012.

Given the short-term pricing pressure that may face the U.S. banking sector in the coming months (see the latest article in the series “Major Headwinds Confront Banking Industry”), it may be difficult to duplicate the stellar returns experienced in the first portfolio and the price appreciation for all bank stocks this year. 

With the success of this first U.S. banking portfolio and the turnaround in the banking sector in general, a new, more stringent set of criteria was used to identify the next list of undervalued U.S. bank stocks. All stocks in the new portfolio meet or exceed the minimum criteria set below:

  • Weiss Financial Strength Rating of C- (Fair) or higher
  • Stock price greater than $2.00 per share as of October 26
  • Average one-month daily trading volume greater than 25,000 shares
  • Positive earnings per share (EPS)
  • Price appreciation potential of at least 10 percent

Other selection criteria include comparing several ratios among the banks: price to book, price to tangible book, current price to 52-week high, forecasted EPS and price target. The table below represents the best selections of all 1,159 publicly traded U.S. banks.

Institution Name



State Weiss Financial Strength Rating1 Stock Price as of 10/26/12 % off High2 Book Value3 Forecast EPS4 Price
Target 5
Forecast  Change
Bank of America Corporation BAC Charlotte NC    C- 9.12 -10% 20.40 0.96 10.97 20.2%
Bank of New York Mellon Corp. BK New York NY    C 24.37 -4% 30.11 2.38 27.28 11.9%
Citigroup Inc. C New York NY    C+ 36.60 -5% 63.59 4.57 52.30 42.9%
JPMorgan Chase & Co.6 JPM New York NY    D+ 41.16 -11% 50.17 5.24 59.93 45.6%
KeyCorp KEY Cleveland OH    B- 8.39 -8% 10.64 0.89 10.20 21.5%
MainSource Financial Group, Inc. MSFG Greensburg IN    C+ 12.23 -9% 15.01 1.25 14.32 17.1%
Oriental Financial Group, Inc. OFG San Juan PR    C- 11.77 -7% 15.21 1.25 14.34 21.8%
PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. PNC Pittsburgh PA    C- 57.76 -15% 66.40 6.60 75.54 30.8%
Regions Financial Corp. RF Birmingham AL    C 6.58 -15% 10.55 0.78 8.97 36.3%
SunTrust Banks, Inc. STI Atlanta GA    C- 27.10 -12% 37.49 2.72 31.14 14.9%

1Weiss Financial Strength rating is based on Q2 2012 data; A=Excellent; B=Good; C=Fair; D=Weak; E=Very Weak; Plus sign=top of grade range; Minus sign=bottom of grade range
2Percentage off one-year stock price high
3Basic book value calculated for the most recent quarter available
4Forecasted EPS is the mean of all analysts' estimates for 2013
5Price target is based on a blended average price-to-earnings ratio (P/E) for all publicly traded banks (11.44x)
6JPMorgan Chase & Co. has a financial strength rating of B- (Good) despite the operating company's rating of D+ (Weak)

This new basket of ten stocks represents the best value available in the banking sector with an average expected return of 29.7 percent over the next twelve months. Five of the names (in bold) were also in the previous basket. They are still included here, because they still represent a good value based on updated price-to-book calculations, adjusted earnings estimates and current prices. Conversely, nine names were dropped from the previous portfolio due to their current prices exceeding their target price or book value as well as low average daily volume (below the 25,000 per month threshold). 

The new group’s average current price is 90 percent of its 52-week high  but just 80  percent of its two-year high and 70 percent of its three-year high. The portfolio’s price-to-basic book value is 0.74, and its price-to-tangible-book value is just six basis points above the average of all publicly traded banks at 1.04. For example, Bank of America (BAC), which has a current price of $9.12 and is 10 percent below its 52-week high, is still 40 percent off its two-year high. BAC’s price is also well off basic and tangible book of $20.40 and $13.16, respectively, which indicates that good value is still available. With the average analysts’ estimates of $0.96 per share for fiscal year 2013, the bank’s forecasted stock price over the next twelve months projects out at $10.97 for a return on investment of 20.2 percent. 

It is reasonable to expect, as with the first basket of undervalued U.S. bank stocks, that the returns of this new basket will exceed the broader market and banking benchmarks.

See also:
Weiss Ratings’ Portfolio of High-Dividend Paying Bank Stocks
U.S. Bank Stock Portfolio Update: +29.72% After Eight Months; Near Full Value
Compare Your Bank to Others
Get unlimited access to Weiss Ratings Reports

To review bank performance, see Weiss Ratings’ complete lists of the strongest and weakest banks at www.weissratings.com/banklists.

Gavin Magor

Gene Kirsch, senior banking analyst at Weiss Ratings, has more than 20 years of financial industry experience in credit-risk management, commercial lending and loan review analysis within various sized credit unions, finance companies and banks at both the retail and commercial level. He leads the firm's bank and thrift ratings division and developed the methodology for Weiss' credit union ratings and global bank ratings.