Coeur Mining, Inc. (CDE) Down 4.8% — Is It Time to Rotate Out?
Key Points
Coeur Mining, Inc. (CDE) ended the latest NYSE session under pressure, sliding 4.77% to close at $16.98. The stock retreated $0.85 from the prior close of $17.83, extending a recent pattern of weakness and losing ground within the precious metals space. Trading activity reached 12.6 million shares, falling below its 90-day average volume of about 17.2 million, suggesting this latest move came on somewhat lighter participation than usual. Even so, the size of the single-day percentage decline underscores the stock’s fragile footing and the ongoing headwinds confronting recent buyers.
From a longer-term perspective, CDE continues to trade well below its 52-week peak of $23.62 set on Oct. 16, 2025, leaving the shares roughly 28% under that high-water mark. This distance from the recent ceiling highlights how much value has eroded as the stock has retreated, with rallies so far failing to reclaim lost territory. In contrast, several sector peers such as Southern Copper Corporation (SCCO), Newmont Corporation (NEM), and Agnico Eagle Mines Limited (AEM) have generally held up better relative to their own highs, reinforcing the view that Coeur Mining is lagging within the broader metals and mining group. Overall, the latest session adds to a pattern of sliding price action that keeps the stock on the defensive and signals that sellers remain in control for now.
Why Coeur Mining, Inc. Price is Moving Lower
The recent weakness in Coeur Mining, Inc. comes despite strong headline fundamentals, suggesting the stock is facing more serious underlying headwinds. Shares have retreated nearly 20% over the past week even as the latest quarter showed revenue of $480.65 million and net income of $70.73 million, both solid improvements and ahead of estimates. That disconnect points to rising concern that the recent operational momentum may already be priced in, particularly with a P/E multiple above 26 in a cyclical, commodities‑linked business. The wide spread in analyst targets — from $12.25 to $26.00 — also underscores uncertainty around the sustainability of current profitability, adding pressure as investors reassess risk versus reward.
Short-term technical and sentiment factors are amplifying that caution. Trading has been heavy relative to recent sessions, with elevated volume accompanying the selloff and a weekly decline approaching 20%, hinting at institutional or fast‑money investors taking profits after a sharp multi-month rally. A neutral RSI, combined with a Fear & Greed reading tilted toward fear, suggests there is room for further downside if sentiment on precious metals or the broader Materials space deteriorates. At the same time, sector peers such as Southern Copper, Newmont, and Agnico Eagle offer diversified exposure and, in some cases, more established production profiles, giving investors alternatives as they rotate away from names perceived as higher beta. Against that backdrop, caution is warranted as the stock digests recent gains and the market re-prices execution and commodity-price risk.
What is the Coeur Mining, Inc. Rating - Should I Sell?
Weiss Ratings assigns CDE a B rating. Current recommendation is Buy. Even with this above-average overall assessment, investors should approach Coeur Mining, Inc. with caution, particularly given the inherent instability in precious metals and the company’s Weak Volatility Index. A Buy-rated stock with poor volatility characteristics can expose shareholders to sharp drawdowns when market sentiment turns or commodity prices retreat.
On the surface, several metrics look impressive. The Excellent Growth Index is supported by revenue growth of 76.91%, while a profit margin of 24.03% and return on equity of 19.57% contribute to a Good Efficiency Index. A forward P/E of 26.37, however, indicates investors are already paying a premium for this growth, leaving less room for error if mining conditions, metal prices, or operating costs move in the wrong direction. The Excellent Solvency Index reduces balance-sheet risk, but it does not eliminate the cyclical and operational risks typical of the Materials space.
The Excellent Total Return Index indicates that past shareholders have been rewarded, yet this is precisely where risk can be underestimated. Strong historical gains often come with elevated downside if performance normalizes or reverses. Compared with peers such as Southern Copper Corporation (SCCO, B), Newmont Corporation (NEM, B), and Agnico Eagle Mines Limited (AEM, A), Coeur’s profile leans more heavily on aggressive growth and volatility rather than stability and income.
In short, CDE’s B (Buy) rating acknowledges its attractive growth and financial strength, but the Weak Volatility Index, premium valuation and sector cyclicality warrant a defensive mindset. Investors should be prepared for potentially large price swings and avoid assuming that recent strong metrics will necessarily protect capital in the next downturn.
About Coeur Mining, Inc.
Coeur Mining, Inc. is a U.S.-based precious metals producer operating within the materials sector, with a primary focus on silver and gold. The company engages in the exploration, development and operation of hard‑rock mining assets across North America. Its portfolio typically includes underground and open‑pit mines, along with associated processing facilities such as crushing, milling and heap‑leach operations. Coeur’s business model centers on extracting and processing ore to produce concentrates and doré bars, which are then sold to metals traders, smelters and refiners. The company also maintains exploration programs around existing sites and in new target areas, seeking to extend mine life and replace depleted reserves, though this exposes it to the inherent technical and geological risks of the mining industry.
Within the materials industry, Coeur positions itself as a mid‑tier precious metals producer rather than a diversified mining major. As a result, it is more exposed to operational disruptions, cost overruns, permitting delays and jurisdictional risks at individual mines. The company’s asset base is concentrated in a limited number of properties, reducing diversification benefits relative to larger global competitors that balance exposure across multiple commodities and regions. Coeur’s operations involve complex metallurgy and challenging mining conditions in several locations, which can pressure operating reliability, recovery rates and unit costs. While the company seeks efficiencies through mine planning, technology deployment and selective capital projects, its competitive profile is constrained by scale, asset concentration and its narrow focus on silver and gold within the broader materials sector.
Investor Outlook
Despite its B (Buy) Weiss Rating, investors should exercise caution with Coeur Mining, Inc. (CDE) by closely monitoring sector-wide metals demand, cost pressures and any shifts in the company’s risk profile that could impact its overall risk/reward balance. Watch how the rating evolves relative to peers and pay attention to broader Materials trends that could pressure sentiment. See full rankings of all B-rated Materials stocks inside the Weiss Stock Screener.
--