McCormick & Company, Incorporated (MKC) Down 8.3% — Should I Liquidate This Holding?
McCormick & Company, Incorporated (MKC) extended its recent slide in the latest session, closing at $61.04 and finishing the day down 8.29%. The stock surrendered $5.52 from the prior close of $66.56, putting shares firmly under pressure and signaling that buyers are losing ground in the near term. Trading activity was heavy, with volume surging to 7,793,447 shares, far above the 90-day average of 2,815,092. That spike in activity underscores the intensity of the latest retreat, as more participants stepped in on the downside rather than offering support.
From a longer-term price perspective, MKC is now trading well below its 52-week peak of $86.24 set on March 10, 2025, leaving the stock roughly $25 off that high-water mark. This distance from the recent top highlights how far the shares have slid, with the recent session adding to a broader pattern of weakness and suggesting the stock remains under sustained pressure. Within the packaged food and beverage space, several large peers such as Pepsico (PEP), Ambev (ABEV), and Hershey (HSY) have generally seen more muted single-day moves in recent trading, making MKC’s sharp pullback stand out as an underperformer in its sector. For now, the price action points to a stock that is facing notable headwinds, with sellers in clear control and little evidence yet of a firm bid stepping in to stabilize the decline.
Why McCormick & Company, Incorporated Price is Moving Lower
McCormick & Company, Incorporated is trading under pressure following its Q4 2025 earnings release, despite consensus expectations for modest top-line and double‑digit earnings growth. Revenue is projected to rise just 2.6% year over year to $1.85 billion, a pace that highlights ongoing headwinds from commodities and tariffs and reinforces concerns that the company’s growth profile remains subdued for a premium‑priced Consumer Staples name. With earnings per share estimated to climb 10% to $0.88, investors appear skeptical that margin improvement alone can offset slow underlying demand growth and integration risks from recent deals, particularly the $750 million Mexico acquisition.
Weakness is also being attributed to valuation and technical pressures. At roughly 23x earnings, McCormick trades at a marked premium to many Food, Beverage and Tobacco peers such as PepsiCo and Mondelez, even as its recent 7‑day decline of 2.9% pulls the share price further below its 200‑day moving average and well off the 52‑week high of $86.24. The apparent disconnect between a discounted cash flow estimate suggesting roughly 36.5% upside to fair value and the market’s willingness to sell the stock signals investor caution about execution, integration of the Mexico expansion, and the durability of its 11.46% profit margin against persistent cost and currency pressures. In this context, steady dividend growth and capital returns have not been sufficient to offset concerns that McCormick’s modest 2.68% revenue growth and premium valuation leave limited room for error, keeping the share price biased to the downside in the near term.
What is the McCormick & Company, Incorporated Rating - Should I Sell?
Weiss Ratings assigns MKC a C rating. Current recommendation is Hold. For investors, that means McCormick & Company, Incorporated sits in the middle of the pack, with a risk/reward profile that does not justify aggressive positioning. Despite operating in the comparatively defensive Consumer Staples space, the stock’s overall profile is only average, which is a concern given its premium valuation and recent price weakness.
On the surface, several operating metrics look attractive. The Excellent Efficiency Index, supported by a 13.85% return on equity and an 11.46% profit margin, shows management is extracting solid profitability from the business. The Good Growth Index, with revenue growth of 2.68%, and the Good Dividend Index further reinforce that the underlying franchise is fundamentally sound. However, these positives have not translated into strong stockholder outcomes.
The biggest red flags lie in the market-facing sub-indices. The Weak Total Return Index signals that investors have not been rewarded for owning MKC, especially relative to the risk taken. The Weak Volatility Index indicates price swings have skewed unfavorably, with downside pressure outweighing upside participation. Layer on a forward P/E of 23.12, and shareholders are paying a premium multiple for what is, at best, moderate growth.
Compared with Consumer Staples peers such as Pepsico, Inc. (PEP, C), Ambev S.A. (ABEV, C), and The Hershey Company (HSY, C), McCormick’s C (Hold) rating does not stand out as a superior opportunity. Given its only average overall rating, weak total return profile, and relatively rich valuation, investors should be cautious about expecting near-term outperformance from MKC.
About McCormick & Company, Incorporated
McCormick & Company, Incorporated is a global consumer staples company focused on flavor products for both retail consumers and food industry customers. Operating within the Food, Beverage and Tobacco industry, McCormick develops, manufactures and markets spices, herbs, seasonings, condiments and other flavorings that are sold under a portfolio of brands as well as private label. Its products are used in meal preparation, snacks, beverages and ready-to-eat foods, embedding the company deeply into everyday food consumption habits across many markets. The business is typically organized around consumer-facing segments and flavor solutions for food manufacturers, with a heavy reliance on established retail distribution channels and relationships with large packaged food and foodservice companies.
The company’s brand lineup includes a range of seasoning blends, spice mixes, sauces, marinades and flavorings positioned as everyday pantry staples in the consumer staples space. McCormick also supplies custom flavor systems, coatings and seasonings to quick-service restaurants, snack producers and large-scale food processors, aiming to lock in long-term relationships and recurring volume. Its scale, long operating history and broad product assortment offer some competitive support, yet the company faces persistent pressure from private-label alternatives, regional spice producers and shifting consumer taste preferences. In a crowded global flavor and ingredients market, McCormick must continually refresh product lines and maintain shelf presence to defend its position against both multinational food companies and lower-cost competitors that can erode brand loyalty and pricing power over time.
Investor Outlook
With McCormick & Company, Incorporated (MKC) carrying a C (Hold) Weiss Rating, investors should exercise caution and closely monitor whether recent price weakness stabilizes or deepens into a more prolonged downtrend. Watch how broader Consumer Staples sector trends evolve, as defensive names can still face pressure if earnings expectations reset or valuation multiples compress. See full rankings of all C-rated Consumer Staples stocks inside the Weiss Stock Screener.
--