States That Adopt New York's Scaffold Safety Law Could Save Hundreds of Lives, Prevent Thousands of Injuries, and Save Billions

NEW YORK, NY, November 20, 2026 — If other states enacted laws modeled on New York's Scaffold Safety Law (Labor Law §240), they could help prevent thousands of construction injuries and hundreds of worker deaths while avoiding billions of dollars in economic losses, according to a new report by Weiss Ratings for the New York Committee for Occupational Safety and Health (NYCOSH).

The report compares New York's construction safety record with Pennsylvania's, a large neighboring industrial state that has never had a statutory liability regime equivalent to §240. After adjusting for New York's far greater volume of multifamily and high-rise construction, New York's 2024 construction injury rate was roughly one-eighth of Pennsylvania's, and its fatality rate less than one-quarter.

Dr. Martin D. Weiss, founder of Weiss Ratings, commented: “New York builds higher than any state in the nation, and yet its construction workers are far less likely to be hurt or killed on the job than workers in a state without such a law. The Scaffold Safety Law is a proven model. Other states should adopt it. And yet lobbyists in New York are pushing hard to weaken or repeal it.”

How the Law Protects Workers

The Scaffold Safety Law places responsibility for elevation-related injuries on the parties best positioned to prevent them. Owners and contractors who fail to provide proper scaffolding, hoists, ladders and other safety devices are liable when a worker is hurt as a result. That gives every owner and general contractor a direct financial reason to make sure fall protection is in place before a worker ever leaves the ground, rather than relying on a regulatory obligation enforced by occasional inspections.

The stakes are high. The New York City Department of Buildings reported that more than half of the construction injuries and work-site fatalities it recorded in 2024 resulted from falls, which remain the leading construction-site hazard.

The Evidence

New York's construction is far more vertical than Pennsylvania's. In 2024, New York authorized 876 new units in buildings of five or more units for every 10,000 construction workers, compared with 277 in Pennsylvania. To compare the two states on equal footing, the report adjusts Pennsylvania's accident rates for this difference in multifamily construction activity, using official 2024 data from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics and the Census Bureau.

Injuries. New York had an estimated 137 construction injuries per 10,000 full-time-equivalent (FTE) workers. Pennsylvania's adjusted injury index was 1,084, nearly eight times New York's (691% higher).

Fatalities. New York recorded 8.9 construction fatalities per 100,000 FTE workers. Pennsylvania's adjusted fatality index was 37.6, more than four times New York's (322% higher).

Lives at stake. To illustrate what that gap means in human terms, the report applies Pennsylvania's adjusted rates to New York's workforce of about 390,400 construction workers. Raising New York's injury rate from 137 to 1,084 would imply an estimated 36,971 additional injuries per year. Raising its fatality rate from 8.9 to 37.6 would imply an estimated 112 additional deaths per year.

Dollars at stake. The report then puts an estimated price on those added accidents, using conservative National Safety Council benchmarks and counting only injuries serious enough to keep a worker off the job. After adjusting for New York’s greater density of multifamily construction,

  • 24,647 additional lost-time injuries, at $48,000 each, would cost $1.183 billion.
  • 112 additional deaths, at $1.54 million each, would cost $172.5 million.
  • Combined, the extra burden would reach an estimated $1.356 billion every year, in New York alone.

These totals exclude costs that are real but hard to measure, such as lifetime attendant care, family caregiving, project delays and costs borne by public disability and health programs. Moreover, they dwarf the law's measurable insurance costs. In the New York City Housing Authority's 2023 project-cost model, all insurance combined represented only about 1% of construction costs, while labor and materials represented 61%. Even the industry-funded "Rockefeller study," frequently cited by opponents of the law, put its most §240-specific estimate of annual claims and legal costs at roughly $110 million.

A Model for the Nation

The gap between New York and Pennsylvania represents tens of thousands of injuries, more than a hundred deaths and nearly $1.4 billion a year in a single state. Multiplied across the states that lack a comparable law, and across years, the potential toll avoided by adopting New York's approach runs to hundreds of lives and billions of dollars.

“Every one of these numbers represents a worker who could go home safely at the end of the day,” Weiss concluded. “Legislatures looking for a proven way to cut construction deaths and the enormous costs that come with them need look no further than New York.”

The full report, Five Risks of Repealing or Weakening New York's Scaffold Safety Law, is available here.

***

About Weiss: Weiss Ratings is the nation’s leading independent provider of 100% unbiased ratings on stocks, ETFs, mutual funds, cryptocurrencies, banks, credit unions and insurance companies, covering more than 60,000 institutions and investments. Since the founding of its predecessor company in New York in 1971, Weiss Ratings has never accepted compensation from the companies it rates, and it never gives rated companies the opportunity to preview or suppress a rating before publication.  The U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO) reported that the Weiss ratings of U.S. life and health insurers outperformed those of AM Best by 3 to 1 in warning of future financial difficulties, while also greatly outperforming those of Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s. The New York Times reported that Weiss “was the first to warn of the dangers and say so unambiguously,” and Barron’s called Weiss Ratings “the leader in identifying vulnerable companies.” All Weiss ratings are available at https://weissratings.com.

About NYCOSH: The New York Committee for Occupational Safety and Health is a nonprofit membership organization of workers, unions, community groups, workers’ rights advocates and health and safety professionals. Founded in 1979 on the principle that workplace injuries, illnesses and deaths are preventable, NYCOSH uses training, education and advocacy to make jobs safer across New York. It has trained more than 100,000 workers in New York City, Long Island and the Hudson Valley, publishes “Deadly Skyline,” its annual report on construction fatalities in New York State, and leads the Scaffold Safety Coalition to protect the Scaffold Safety Law. Learn more at https://nycosh.org.