A
Preferred Mutual Ins Co
Rating Date
October 2025
NAIC
Classification
Property & Casualty
Risk Adjusted
Capital Ratio #1
4.12
Risk Adjusted
Capital Ratio #2
2.78
Loss
Ratio
63.62%
Total
Assets
710.69M
Capital
284.67M
Net
Premiums
178.88M
Net
Income
5.94M
My Lists My Alerts
Weiss Ratings Preferred Mutual Ins Co
New Berlin, NY 		Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare
Rating A
Capitalization Index 9.70
Investment Safety Index --
Liquidity Index 7.00
Profitability Index 5.00
Reserve Adequacy Index 8.10
Stability Index 7.10
Company Info Preferred Mutual Ins Co
New Berlin, NY 		Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare
Industry P&C
NAIC Number 15024
Phone Number (607) 847-6161
Website www.preferredmutual.com
Address One Preferred Way New Berlin, NY 13411
Balance Sheet Preferred Mutual Ins Co
New Berlin, NY 		Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare
Total Assets 710.69M
Capital and Reserves Preferred Mutual Ins Co
New Berlin, NY 		Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare
Risk-Adjusted Capital Ratio #1 4.12
Risk-Adjusted Capital Ratio #2 2.78
1-Year Reserve Development -40.00%
2-Year Reserve Development -570.00%
Capital 284.67M
Premium to Surplus 120.00%
Reserves to Surplus 70.00%
Investments Preferred Mutual Ins Co
New Berlin, NY 		Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare
Cash --
CMO & Structured Securities --
Common & Preferred Stock --
Invested Assets --
Investments in Affiliates --
Mortgages in Good Standing --
Non-Investment Grade Bonds --
Non-Performing Mortgages --
Other Investment Grade Bonds --
Other Investments --
Real Estate --
Operating Ratios Preferred Mutual Ins Co
New Berlin, NY 		Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare
Medical Loss Ratio --
Cash From Underwriting 110.00%
Combined Ratio 100.00%
Expense Ratio 40.00%
Loss Ratio 63.62%
Net Premium Growth 20.00%
Other Medical Preferred Mutual Ins Co
New Berlin, NY 		Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare
Bonus Pay --
Capitation Pay --
Contractual Pay --
Enrollment --
Fee For Service --
Medical Expense Per Member Per Month --
Network Physicians --
Other Pay --
Salary Pay --
Total Patient Encounters - Physician --
Total Patient Encounters-Non-Physician --
Profitability Preferred Mutual Ins Co
New Berlin, NY 		Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare		 Click to
Compare
Net Income 5.94M
Net Premium 178.88M
Health Premium --