Breaking Up Big Tech Will Be Sweet Sorrow

Washington lawmakers are about to mount their assault on perceived anticompetitive practices at big tech companies. That means investors should buy, Inc. (Nasdaq: AMZN, Rated “B”), Apple Inc. (Nasdaq: AAPL, Rated “B”), Alphabet Inc. (Nasdaq: GOOGL, Rated “B-”) and Facebook, Inc. (Nasdaq: FB, Rated “B-”).

According to a document filed the House Judiciary committee, after a 15 month investigation, it was recommended that the biggest tech companies in the world be broken up.

It’s a dumb idea that will be great for existing shareholders.

Source: Common Dreams

Lawmakers assume that big tech companies were always destined to be such. Worse, they believe the companies must have cheated in order to win rather than simply innovating, and yes, in some cases copying, faster and more effectively than their competitors.

When started Amazon Web Services (AWS), its market-leading cloud computing platform, there was no immediate market for pay-as-you-go virtual computers and cloud-based data storage. In 2004, AWS was the backend for The innovation was the move toward open source standards and application programming interfaces.

This strategy helped many fledgling businesses ultimately become much larger.

For example, Netflix, Inc. (Nasdaq: NFLX, Rated “C+”) grew from a sleepy mail-order DVD rental company into a global streaming media giant with AWS as its partner. There are similar origin stories for DropBox, Inc. (Nasdaq: DBX, Rated “D”), Pinterest, Reddit and SpaceX.

Facebook and Alphabet have become popular targets among lawmakers because the companies command so much mindshare online. Their properties — WhatsApp, Instagram, Google Search and YouTube — represent the lion’s share of all smartphone downloads.

This is not for of lack of competition. They built better products members actually wanted to use.

It’s easy to forget that in most cases, these online properties are competing for attention with billions of websites all over the internet.

And while Apple may very well have a monopoly over iPhone and iPad applications, it’s naïve to assume keeping credit card and other personal information safe, or securing against malicious software, has no value. The power of the Apple ecosystem is its App Store safety.

To be sure, there have been some abuses in big tech.

Related post: Short-term Tech Pain Won’t Last Long product managers shouldn’t be able to use internal data to spot, develop and undercut hot-selling products in its online store. Google Search should be more careful about appropriating and monetizing content collected by its search algorithms. And Apple certainly should not be taking 30% of Spotify Technology S.A. (NYSE: SPOT, Rated “D”) subscription fees from iPhone and iPad users when Apple Music is the single biggest competitor.

These failings need to be fixed but breaking up the companies misses the mark.

This is mostly because that remedy will not fix anything. Big tech companies, even splintered, will retain their most trusted status. Amazon and Google ranked second and third, respectively, of the most trusted brands in America, (only behind the U.S. Postal Service) in a Morning Consult poll. Facebook has 2.3 billion monthly active users. And Apple customer loyalty is the envy of the consumer tech world.

However, even if lawmakers do split AWS from, sever Instagram and WhatsApp from Facebook and cleave off YouTube and Google Search away from Alphabet, shareholders will still own the spun-out businesses.

These businesses are extremely valuable in their own right.

If they are ultimately freed, the sum of the parts is worth much more than the current stock prices of, Facebook and Alphabet.

Given the nature of the App Store, I doubt Apple can or will be broken up.

Related post: Big Tech Hopes to Combat COVID-19 Hindered by Privacy Hawks

Last October, a Needham analyst advocated that YouTube should be spun out of Alphabet. She claimed the video site might be worth $300 billion as a standalone company based on enterprise value and revenues. Analysts in the past have pegged the value of Google Search between $700 billion to $800 billion.

At current prices, investors would be getting Google Cloud, its fast-growing cloud computing business, and $100 billion in cash sitting on the balance sheet for free.

It isn’t hard to understand why Washington politicians want to breakup big tech. Lawmakers think the companies are too powerful. However, big tech is not harming consumers with higher prices and their services remain wildly popular.

Ultimately, investors should hope those services are set free. In the interim, buy any weakness that arises out of breakup speculation.

Best wishes,

Jon D. Markman

About the Editor

Jon D. Markman is winner of the prestigious Gerald Loeb Award for outstanding financial journalism and the Society of Professional Journalists' Sigma Delta Chi award. He was also on Los Angeles Times staffs that won Pulitzer Prizes for coverage of the 1992 L.A. riots and the 1994 Northridge earthquake. He invented Microsoft’s StockScouter, the world’s first online app for analyzing and picking stocks.

Top Tech Stocks
See All »
Top Consumer Staple Stocks
See All »
WMT NYSE $58.66
Top Financial Stocks
See All »
V NYSE $283.77
JPM NYSE $185.08
Top Energy Stocks
See All »
Top Health Care Stocks
See All »
Top Real Estate Stocks
See All »
Weiss Ratings