Opportunity or Hype: 3 Experts Weigh in on a Spot Bitcoin ETF

by Jurica Dujmovic
By Jurica Dujmovic

In a market as dynamic as crypto, a single tweet can set off a cascade of reactions, as my colleagues Marija and Alex broke down in their respective issues earlier this week in regard to the spot Bitcoin (BTC, “A-”) ETF rumors.  (You can find both on our website here.)

The spotlight on Bitcoin ETFs is not new, but it has certainly intensified this week. ETFs are marketable securities that track an index, commodity, bonds or a basket of assets like an index fund, but are traded on stock exchanges, much like individual stocks. 

A Bitcoin ETF would allow investors to access the cryptocurrency market without the need to handle Bitcoin directly. And in so doing would provide a simplified, regulated and safer gateway to the burgeoning digital asset class.

The speculation around which Bitcoin ETF might cross the regulatory finish line first has fostered a whirlwind of discussions. Yet, the primary question remains: Will the approval of a Bitcoin ETF be a watershed moment for the crypto market or just fleeting hype? 

While the Cointelegraph incident showcases the market's pent-up anticipation, the broader implications of such an ETF are far-reaching and complex. The discourse extends beyond mere approval to its market ramifications, the ensuing BTC rally and whether the current market prices have factored in the potential ETF approval.

You’ve already read what our team’s thoughts are yesterday. Today, I’m bringing you some outside perspectives from three crypto experts. 

My first guest is Igor Telyatnikov, CEO of AlphaPoint, a financial technology firm that offers solutions for institutional operators providing access to digital assets and cryptocurrencies globally.

Telyatnikov recognizes this development as a precursor to a potential bullish cycle, emphasizing the current pent-up demand and the significance of a BTC ETF in democratizing Bitcoin access to a broader populace.

He notes, “The reason a BTC ETF is important is because only a small percentage, sub 20% of the population has invested in BTC or ever held the asset. The BTC ETF allows everyday Americans, who have never opened an account at a crypto exchange, to access BTC through their normal investment vehicles.”

In essence, a spot ETF would make investing in crypto as simple as buying a mutual fund. This would be a boon for adoption for retail investors previously wary of crypto, particularly in the multistep onboarding process. By wrapping Bitcoin exposure in a highly accessible format, a BTC ETF is envisioned to bridge the gap between traditional investment avenues and the cryptosphere. 

Telyatnikov opines that for most consumers, this ease of access would be a game changer, providing a straightforward pathway to invest in Bitcoin.

This perspective sheds light on the immense potential a BTC ETF holds in propelling the cryptocurrency market to new horizons by tapping into a new demographic of investors. 

Graeme Moore, the Head of Tokenization at Polymesh Association — an institutional-grade permissioned blockchain built specifically for regulated assets —  lends a different perspective.

Reflecting on past interactions between the SEC and Bitcoin spot ETF applicants, Moore notes a shift in the regulatory landscape. Unlike previous instances where the SEC merely delayed and eventually rejected applications, this time around, there seems to be a constructive dialogue. The regulatory body is offering feedback to applicants, suggesting requisite amendments for their proposals. 

This new dynamic — coupled with the entrance of major U.S. financial firms into the ETF arena, recent approvals of Bitcoin futures ETFs and the SEC’s decision not to challenge its recent legal setback against Grayscale — paints a promising picture for the imminent approval of a Bitcoin spot ETF on American soil.

Based on this, Moore is entertaining the possibility of multiple Bitcoin spot ETFs receiving approval concurrently, potentially by the close of the current year.

The ramifications of such an approval, according to Moore, are colossal. He elucidates, “The consequences of a Bitcoin spot ETF being approved in the U.S. are massive” because of the implications for institutional investors. 

See, many funds and managers are only able to purchase ETFs based on their bylaws and mandates. A BTC spot ETF means the trillions of dollars held by pension funds and investment managers can easily flow into Bitcoin.  This influx of institutional capital is expected to not only propel Bitcoin’s price but also create a ripple effect across the digital asset spectrum.

Reflecting on the recent BTC rally triggered by false ETF approval rumors, Moore underscores the market’s eager anticipation and the potential surge awaiting upon actual approval. He comments, “Even though the rumor was false and only reported by a handful of outlets without any evidence, the price spiked 10% in minutes. Imagine what the real news, with trillions of dollars flowing into Bitcoin, will do.”

Moore also hints at a larger narrative, contemplating a synergistic effect between a U.S. Bitcoin spot ETF approval, the purge of subpar and fraudulent enterprises post-2021 and the upcoming Bitcoin halving in 2024 in catalyzing the next Bitcoin bull run.

Finally, Stefan Rust, CEO of independent data aggregator Truflation, focuses on two cardinal advantages a Bitcoin ETF approval would usher in: broad market stability and enhanced liquidity.

And it extends beyond Bitcoin.

Rust argues that the existing scenario — where investors can hedge against BTC volatility using approved ETF BTC futures yet still buy the underlying asset through an exchange, is incongruous, especially amidst the SEC's advocacy for market stability. He envisages a significant liquidity uptick as institutions managing colossal funds on behalf of pension funds and unions could allocate a portion of their portfolios to Bitcoin. 

This liquidity infusion, Rust contends, would drive substantial demand for Bitcoin, nudging its price significantly upward given its limited supply.

Reflecting on the recent BTC rally following incorrect news about BlackRock’s ETF approval, just like the other experts, Rust underscores the market's keen anticipation for a Bitcoin spot ETF. He anticipates a liquidity ripple effect post-approval, initiating with Bitcoin before extending to Ethereum (ETH, “B”) and eventually percolating down to selected altcoins. 

This liquidity cascade, according to Rust, would not only bolster the crypto asset class but also reaffirm cryptocurrencies as both investments and utilities.

Indeed, my colleague Juan Villaverde shares this sentiment. It’s why he’s analyzing the market to find the altcoins with the biggest growth potential for his members. And there’s one he recommends getting leveraged to now, ahead of the liquidity cascade.

To learn more about it, I suggest you watch his latest video

Clearly, the unfolding narrative around Bitcoin ETFs has the crypto community on the edge of its seat. The recent misfire by CoinTelegraph not only showcased the market's hair-trigger response but also the colossal potential that lies within a single regulatory nod. 

Experts I’ve spoken to have painted a vibrant picture of a market teetering on the brink of evolution, with a Bitcoin ETF serving as a potential catalyst.

As we delve through these insights, a vision of democratized Bitcoin access, amplified liquidity and a bridge to mainstream investment unfold. The excitement surrounding the recent BTC rally, though triggered by false news, underscores a pent-up eagerness that may just be the tip of the iceberg. 

Still, seasoned investors will know the danger of buying into a narrative without further examination. They know, as my colleague Chris Coney cautions frequently, the dangers of letting optimism be the father of investment decisions. 

And knowing the fickle and volatile nature of crypto market, one question remains: Are we about to witness a watershed moment that could redefine the contours of cryptocurrency investment, or is the market chasing a mirage in a regulatory desert?

We will find out soon enough. 




About the Contributor

Jurica Dujmović has been a creator, collector and investor in digital art, including the rapidly evolving non-fungible tokens (NFT) space since its inception nearly a decade ago. He’s also passionate about digital currencies and writes about crypto trends, including what’s new in the Weiss Crypto Ratings, in Weiss Crypto Daily. 

See All »
ETH $3,486.58
ALGO $0.158381
ADA $0.424064
SOL $148.21
UNI $10.03
ZRX $0.468027
AAVE $84.10
ARB $0.955875
CRO $0.100912
MKR $2,254.37
Crypto Ratings
Weiss Ratings